Adobe Stock / mimagephotos
Whether to trade once-loved items or find designer and vintage steals, these local consignment stores are the place to go.
By Cloey Callahan and Sabrina Sucato
There’s something so special about vintage clothing. Maybe it has to do with the lives the pieces lived or the history they held, but consignment stores allow these treasures to live at least a little longer. Plus, consignment is a way to be more sustainable that most people can get behind.
Ready to shop and score in the Hudson Valley? Visit these secondhand spots with an open mind, since you never know what you might find.
Albany County
View this post on Instagram
PolkaDots Consignment Shop, Guilderland
With a presence in the Capital Region for over 15 years, this women-owned shop stocks clothing for the whole family. PolkaDots has very clear guidelines when it comes to trading in clothing, with both “fast cash” and consignment options available. As far as brands go, keep an eye out for everything from Michael Kors to Nike to Nordstrom.
Columbia County
View this post on Instagram
The Attic, Valatie
Located on Main Street in Valatie, this consignment store always accepts new consigners, and appointments are encouraged for anyone looking to come in and sell. For those who want to shop, The Attic has everything from furniture to clothing and accessories that rotate frequently. There is an eclectic mix of modern, retro, and vintage pieces at this small business.
Dutchess County
View this post on Instagram
Blackbird Attic, Beacon
This curated consignment boutique (which won for Best Vintage Consignment Shop and Best Bargain Shopping in our 2019 Best of Hudson Valley Awards) is one that fans of repurposed clothing won’t want to skip. The collection is almost always rotating with modern and bohemian styles. For anyone interested in selling, there is a minimum five-item policy, and appraisals are by appointment only. To really luck out selling here, bring brands like Anthropologie, Free People, Revolve, Reformation, Madewell, and Zara. Blackbird Attic gives 40 percent of the sale price to the consigner.
View this post on Instagram
Hyde Park Consignments, Hyde Park
Wipe of the dust on any potentially collectible clothes and head on over to Hyde Park. No appointment is necessary, and the consignment rate is 50/50 with items needing to be sold within 60 days. Don’t skip out on the selection of in-season clothing, polished shoes, jewelry, and even books and CDs.
Past ‘n’ Perfect, Pleasant Valley
Past ‘n’ Perfect owner Lynne McCarthy has been curating the finds at this Pleasant Valley storefront since 2012, although the shop itself dates back to 1982. As for what to expect, there’s a delightful variety of styles and accessories available, with inventory rotating regularly. Appointments are required for consignment, and items sit on the floor for two months before being discounted half off.
View this post on Instagram
Simplicity Consign, Poughkeepsie
Set up an appointment at Simplicity to see exactly how much money might be sitting in your closet. The store doesn’t fall short with consigners bringing clothing, handbags, accessories, and furniture. Simplicity accepts brands like Loft, Banana Republic, Talbots, Free People, Gap, and Coldwater Creek. While you’re there, keep an eye out for the rotating selection of designer and vintage items on offer.
Topanga, Poughkeepsie
With a bohemian-chic vibe and a prime location on Main Street, Topanga is a must for fashion lovers in Poughkeepsie. In addition to clothing, the store also carries a selection of furniture, with designs trending toward mid-century modern.
View this post on Instagram
Treasures of the Valley, Wappingers Falls
If you’ve spotted this storefront while cruising along West Main Street in Wappingers Falls, consider this your sign to stop in and see what the hype is all about. Owner Eimee DeRise leans into casual, elegant styles, with a variety of designer and vintage items in the mix. P.S. Can’t make it into the shop? Check out the online storefront to browse from the comfort of your couch.
View this post on Instagram
Vintage: Beacon, Beacon
No day trip to Beacon is complete without a stop into Vintage: Beacon to see what owner and stylist Angela Hastings has in rotation. The goodies here range from designer to vintage (or both!), with brands running the gamut from Anthropologie to Chanel. Interested in consigning? Make an appointment beforehand, and keep in mind that 10 pieces need to be accepted for the store to make an account for you.
Orange County
View this post on Instagram
Cream Vintage & Consignment, Newburgh
Cream sits at the heart of Newburgh and features a wide range of products at fair prices. Shoppers can browse hard-to-find items from brands like Louis Vuitton, Christian Dior, Chanel, and Gucci. Hop online to peruse Cream’s eye-catching inventory to order from the comfort of home, with both home shipping and in-store pickup options available. Don’t miss out on shoppable gems from our Best of Hudson Valley 2022 consignment shop winner.
View this post on Instagram
Reclaimed Consignment Boutique, Warwick
As its name suggests, Reclaimed is all about eco-friendly fashion in Warwick. The storefront carries a range of sizes for women, with options from petite to plus size, along with a variety of accessories. No appointment is necessary to consign items, and consignor splits vary based on the price of the item for sale.
Putnam County
DamnAged Vintage, Cold Spring
Since June 2019, DamnAged Vintage has been serving up serious fashion inspiration in Cold Spring. Owner Judiann Romanello embraces her visual merchandising background to craft a storefront that’s as inspiring as it is shoppable. Go for the designer goods, then stay for a shop through some of the more one-of-a-kind items.
Rockland County
View this post on Instagram
Style on Lafayette, Suffern
The long-standing store in the heart of Suffern was featured in the Netflix movie The Half of It and offers top designer names and brand-new items. Consigners can bring in a maximum of 20 items at a time. Items remain on consignment for 60 days, and brands include Gucci, Hermes, Yves Saint Laurent, Chanel, Jimmy Choo, Lilly Pulitzer, and Jeffrey Campbell. This store prides itself on promoting sustainable shopping by giving stylish clothing a new life.
Ulster County
View this post on Instagram
Uptown Attic, Gardiner
Uptown Attic stocks consigned goodies for women, teens, and children in Gardiner. Notably, the store offers a variety of plus-size styles, as well as an ample selection of jewelry and accessories. Labels found at the storefront range from Missoni to Tahari and Tory Burch, with inventory rotating regularly. In other words, there’s always an excuse to plan a visit.
Ohioville Consignment, New Paltz
A mainstay in Ulster County since 2011, Ohioville Consignment is a hub for quirky, cool finds. Prospective consignors should call ahead to schedule an appointment, which is required. There’s a limit of 25 items, or 10 in-season items, per appointment. Consignment terms run 60 days; after that, consignors can choose to either pick up their items or donate them.
