Hudson Valley Burgers 2011 Review: The Wherehouse, Newburgh, NY

The Wherehouse in Newburgh, NY

“It’s like a carnivore’s dream in here,” says Dan Brown, owner of the Wherehouse restaurant/bar/live music venue. Although it also caters to vegetarians and in-betweens, the eatery — which maintains a retro vibe, with walls decked out in ’60s and ’70s concert posters — offers almost 40 varieties of Angus and Kobe beef burgers.

Brown says they serve “everything from the standard cheeseburger to oddballs.” Examples of the latter include the Soul Burger ($8.95), topped with mac-and-cheese; Rasta Man Vibration ($9.95), with jerk-grilled onions and mango chutney; the Boston ($9.50), with baked beans and cheddar; and the Wowvocado ($10.95): fried onions, lettuce, tomato, and avocado, stacked tall and sloppy. (“You need a knife and fork or two very large hands to eat it,” Brown says.)

The list of unique burgers is ever-expanding. Two of this summer’s newcomers are the Fat City (eight ounces of Angus, two ounces of andouille sausage) and the Lucha Libre — an homage to mask-wearing Mexican wrestlers, with crumbled chorizo sausage and jalapeño-jack cheese shaped into a mask.

- Advertisement -

Besides oddball burgers, the Wherehouse offers a huge selection of brews; choose from bottled craft beers from around the world or have a pint poured from one of the 16 rotating taps. Ask a staff member for a suggested pairing if you can’t decide which to try; Brown suggests a Brooklyn Summer Ale with the Soul Burger or a Leinenkugel Summer Shandy with the Wowvocado.

If you visit in the evening, chances are you’ll find a live music group at the back of the restaurant. Bands, duos, and other performers can be heard at least three — and as many as five — times a week, says Brown. The stage is tucked far enough away that the music doesn’t interfere with conversation — just don’t talk with your mouth full.

» Return to the Hudson Valley’s Best Burgers 2011

» Visit The Wherehouse in Newburgh, NY
» Visit the Hudson Valley Dining Guide
» Visit the Hudson Valley Food & Drink Guide


Our Digital Partners

Learn how to become a digital partner ...

Our Excellence in Nursing Awards take place on May 1!

Our Best of Hudson Valley ballot is open through March 31!

Unveiled: A Boutique Bridal Brunch is February 25!

Holiday flash sale ... subscribe and save 50%

Limited time offer. New subscribers only.