Originally built in the 1950s, Cherry Top is a soft-serve haven. Owned by the Best-Hall and Bartholomew families for the past 20 years, this dairy bar rotates through more than 26 different soft-serve flavors throughout the season — adding more each year. Customers delight in choices like blue raspberry, cappuccino, watermelon, and cotton candy; flavors of the week are posted on Facebook. “We’re very proud of the quality of our product,” says Carolyn Best-Hall. “It’s a high butterfat treat, and it’s really tasty.” If you’re in the mood for hard ice cream, Cherry Top has 30 Hershey’s flavors to choose from.
Our Favorite Treat: The s’more shake with graham crackers, marshmallows, and Hershey syrup, mixed with your choice of vanilla or chocolate ice cream
949 Rt 32, Newburgh
Open Seasonally. Summer Hours: Sunday-Thursday, noon to 10 p.m.; Friday & Saturday, noon to 11 p.m.