New TV: Winners and Losers

Poptional names this season’s best (and worst) new shows on television

This week marks the unofficial start of the new TV season. Gone are the summer’s reality shows and time-filling, cheapo series — and in comes a glorious week of new premiere after new premiere.

Except... not all of the new shows look so hot.

So, which ones have jumped out to an early lead? I checked in with to see what the critics had to say. So far, these have risen to the top of the pack:

Boardwalk Empire
This is not surprising, considering that the show is produced by the great Martin Scorsese. The series takes place in 1920s Atlantic City, which means it is beautifully art-directed, and stars perma-sleazeball Steve Buscemi as a politician trying to weasel his way around Prohibition laws for his own profit. These are all fun things. Unfortunately, the show is only available if you have HBO, but HBO seems to be where the best TV is migrating.

Unlike Boardwalk Empire, this show’s slot at the top of the Metacritic list is a total surprise. Terriers? (What? Is it about dogs?) And, unlike Boardwalk Empire, it has no, well, pedigree. Its biggest star is Donal Logue, who you’ll recognize as “that guy” (with Ed Burns in The Groomsmen and on the boob tube in Grounded For Life). It’s not on the splashy HBO, but on the gritty FX network. And it’s about a private detective — one of many already gracing the TV. But critics give it praise for being smarter and more interesting than most P.I. series, and Logue is known for his great character performances, so it might be worth giving it a shot.

boardwalk empireBoardwalk Empire’s glitz and glamour (and the fact that Scorcese is involved) put it at the top of our list of can’t-miss TV this fall

Critics aren’t in love with this re-do of the Luc Besson film/USA series, which now airs on the CW. But they say it’s a sexy good time, and not as dark and heavy as the USA series — good if you’re looking for some mindless entertainment.

... and, so far, the season’s biggest loser:

Sorry, Jimmy Smits, it seems as if your TV projects never quite catch fire. On the 100-point scale, his new outing — about a former Supreme Court justice who decides to go back to practicing law to help the little guy — only scored a 36. “Ludicrous” and “ridiculous” are the words used most often to describe it. Ouch. And, with a billion other lawyer shows to choose from, it doesn’t look like this one is needed.

I’ll check in with the old Metacritic meter again once the initial wave of TV excitement has died down, and we can see which new series deserve that season pass on the DVR. In the meantime, which of these sound the most (or the least) appealing to you? Let me know in the comments box below.

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Pop Culture in Hudson Valley

About This Blog

Marisa LaScala

Marisa LaScala
Elmsford, NY

Associate Editor Marisa LaScala joined Westchester magazine in 2003, and ever since she's blown every paycheck at the Greenburgh Multiplex. She also staunchly defends Richard Kelly, doesn't mind spoiling the endings of trashy movies you're curious about but don't want to pay to see, wishes the Hold Steady would come back and rock out Westchester, misses Arrested Development more than anyone can imagine, and still watches cartoons and Saturday Night Live. You can find more of her cultural criticism at, where she is a staff writer.



Recent Posts

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Our free, totally awesome newsletter

Sign up for Hudson Valley Today!

Sign up for Hudson Valley Today!

Sign me up for VIP offers, too!

Edit Module
Edit Module